BCM Community

Bus Discussion => Bus Topics ( click here for quick start! ) => Topic started by: buddydawg on July 06, 2014, 07:44:24 AM

Title: Try to decide on new wheels Steel v Aluminum
Post by: buddydawg on July 06, 2014, 07:44:24 AM
Doing some routine maintenance I have noticed that one of my steel wheels has a few hairline cracks.  I inspected the rest and didn't find anymore that were visible but I did find some date stamps on the rims.  It looks like most of them were made in 1978.  I am considering my options about what route I would like to take to replace my aging wheels. The main decision I must make is whether to go back with the steel wheels or change to aluminum.

First my bus uses rims with these specs: Hub-Piloted Dual-Mounting Two-Piece Flanged Nut 10-Hole, 11 1/4" Bolt Circle, 8.66" Bore Special Bus Application with 1.22" Bolt Holes.

What are the benefits of swapping over to aluminum (Accuride 28632)?

I will have to replace all of the wheel studs, what is the best place to source these? (Note the special size)

Is it feasible to replace the studs my self or should I just pay to have it done?  I prefer to do it myself if possible, I have not been able to find anyone nearby that I trust to work on my bus. 

I thought about just going back with the steel they are a little cheaper but I was leaning towards changing the studs anyway so why not take the chance to upgrade.

Title: Re: Try to decide on new wheels Steel v Aluminum
Post by: georgemci102a2 on July 06, 2014, 10:11:00 AM
Sent you a pm.  George ;D
Title: Re: Try to decide on new wheels Steel v Aluminum
Post by: Ed Hackenbruch on July 06, 2014, 10:38:05 AM
Just a little over $100 for a new steel wheel vs. probably a couple of hundred for used Al. wheels and more for new?  I always thought that i wanted to have Al. wheels but when the time came i went with steel and don't regret it.  :)
Title: Re: Try to decide on new wheels Steel v Aluminum
Post by: Boomer on July 06, 2014, 10:41:06 AM
IMHO you should go aluminum.  They are forged and precision made resulting in being able to use much less weight (or none) to balance them. They are lighter.  They are rust proof.  They look great and always will with some routine cleaning and polishing once a year.  Steel wheels are not a precision manufactured product, but two pieces that are welded together.  I went through 10 new Accuride steel wheels just to get 6 that didn't wobble on the spin balancer.  This is why most OEM over the road equipment rides on aluminum these days.  As far as the studs, you may be able to install new longer studs on the front without pulling the hub.  Remove the drum and turn the hub to a position the the stud can be inserted through from the back. If using press in studs put a large washer on the end of the stud and pull it in tight with a thimble (inner wheel nut) and a 1" drive air gun.  Yeah, I can hear all the experts saying now that it will stretch the threads. Or, you might be able to use a stud with the threaded end that uses a nut on the inside if you can get a socket and gun on the back side.  You will be fine, this is from someone that has been doing his own fleet tire and brake work for 35 years.  You won't need longer studs on the drive axle, you can use longer inner nuts (thimbles) to make up the difference of the thicker wheels. You will of course need all new thimbles and outer nuts for the aluminum. Another option is to just run steel on the inside of the drive axle.  Sometimes a very thin plastic wafer is used between the wheels to prevent corrosion in this application. HTH
Title: Re: Try to decide on new wheels Steel v Aluminum
Post by: luvrbus on July 06, 2014, 10:46:20 AM
 ::) with aluminum wheels the bus will look fully dressed also JMO
Title: Re: Try to decide on new wheels Steel v Aluminum
Post by: Cary and Don on July 06, 2014, 10:57:57 AM
I could be wrong on this.  I think I read someplace that aluminum wheels dissipate heat from brakes faster than steel.

Cary
Title: Re: Try to decide on new wheels Steel v Aluminum
Post by: wg4t50 on July 06, 2014, 11:01:15 AM
Sure agree on the looks dept.  Howsomever my experience using the aluminum outter rim on the:drive, becomes nearly impossivle to simply check or add air to the inside wheel unless you have the exact items.  I decided it was tine to ditch the 22.5 for the 24.5, bought all new steel, then one day found two nice Alcosz's for the frobt.
Also on the MCI tag, the aluminum rin tends to get nicked up a lot from chips off the drive tires. You can make qa flap to deflect stobes from the tag, I just went steel. Am more gear head than beauty Class, never had a failure on the road in over 20 years and 150,000 miles.
Dave M
Title: Re: Try to decide on new wheels Steel v Aluminum
Post by: Boomer on July 06, 2014, 11:06:02 AM
With aluminum duals, you run a valve stem extension and a rubber isolator (or stabilizer) that presses into the wheel hole.  Makes it real easy to air up.  You can also use a gator instead of a conventional valve stem cap then you never have a cap to remove, just put the inflator right on it.
Title: Re: Try to decide on new wheels Steel v Aluminum
Post by: buddydawg on July 06, 2014, 05:01:45 PM
Look like I am going to go with the Accuride Aluminum wheels.  I am also leaning to replacing all of the wheel studs.  They have been there for a very long time and more than a few are hard to tighten (as in when you put the nuts on they require a good bit of force to get them to snug, definitely not free spinning) 

Does anyone have a good online source for studs and nuts?  Don't forget that my bus uses a hub piloted rim with 1.22" bolt holes and two-pieced flange nuts.
Title: Re: Try to decide on new wheels Steel v Aluminum
Post by: Boomer on July 06, 2014, 05:25:23 PM
Luke or Mohawk.
Title: Re: Try to decide on new wheels Steel v Aluminum
Post by: buddydawg on July 06, 2014, 05:34:01 PM
Thanks Boomer
Title: Re: Try to decide on new wheels Steel v Aluminum
Post by: wg4t50 on July 06, 2014, 05:49:18 PM
When I put new Michelins on my present coach, I had all new stems incuding the 8" long ones for the inner dual, also used the donut snubbers (2) in the outter rim to hold it stable, also installed the Pressure Pro sensors. turned the outter stems outward so were easy to access.
For the first time I do not have any air loss since the installation back in Nov 2013,  Guess between the new stems, and no extensions, and new seals in the pressure pros, all is holding so far, That is a change, had been an on going major PITA.
Dave M
Title: Re: Try to decide on new wheels Steel v Aluminum
Post by: Brian Diehl on July 07, 2014, 07:46:10 AM
I just had to replace a couple of studs on my front hub due to one failing and dissappearing during our last outing.  Each stud came to $11.50 plus shipping from Mohawk.  Replacing all the studs is an easy process if you have a high power impact gun.  Otherwise, it can be extremely had to break the nuts on the studs on the back side of the hub loose.  I highly recommend removing the hubs unless you have some sort of portable press that allows you to get behind the hub and push the studs out.  Removing the hubs also allows you to inspect the condition of the bearings and replace the hub oil all at the same time.  A lot of labor to be sure, but if you haven't been in the hubs before the peace of mind would be worth it.  Keep in mind the worst part of the whole process may be removing the drums from the hubs.  Those screws that hold the drums to the hubs are usually corroded in solid and require drilling and taping to replace.  Put lots of anti-sieze on when you replace!
Title: Re: Try to decide on new wheels Steel v Aluminum
Post by: Jim Eh. on July 07, 2014, 10:59:05 AM
If it has been a long time since the bearings were checked , why not pull the hubs at the same time, check the bearings, replace the seals, and press the new studs in with a hydraulic press to ensure proper seating of the studs? Preventative maintenance goes a long way in reducing your overall costs.
Title: Re: Try to decide on new wheels Steel v Aluminum
Post by: Charles in SC on July 08, 2014, 07:41:18 PM
Are you sure your wheels have cracks in them or could it just be cracks in the paint? My 5303 has steel wheels and they are thick and heavy built as a tank. I cannot imagine any way you could crack one. I painted mine silver to give them the aluminum look. I am in the "if it aint broke dont fix it" corner.
Title: Re: Try to decide on new wheels Steel v Aluminum
Post by: belfert on July 08, 2014, 08:28:52 PM
I had a steel wheel crack where the wheel was welded together under the tire.  The crack was causing my new tire to leak down overnight.  It took several trips back to the tire dealer before they found the problem.
Title: Re: Try to decide on new wheels Steel v Aluminum
Post by: Nineforever on July 08, 2014, 09:46:44 PM
Good quality steel wheels maintained are the way to go fancy inserts are okay as long as your stud wheel nuts are not hidden   ,,,, Aluminum stud pilot wheels can be trouble be there done that .
Title: Re: Try to decide on new wheels Steel v Aluminum
Post by: chessie4905 on July 09, 2014, 06:00:19 PM
   I've wondered about chrome plated steel wheels. Anyone done that?
Title: Re: Try to decide on new wheels Steel v Aluminum
Post by: luvrbus on July 10, 2014, 06:25:54 AM
They say the tire bead won't seat on on chrome plated wheels I read an article on that 20 years ago in a truckers magazine, aluminum wheels are the way to go I saw only a few with center ripped out and have saw stacks of the steel wheels with the center gone FWIW
Title: Re: Try to decide on new wheels Steel v Aluminum
Post by: trucktramp on July 10, 2014, 08:03:51 AM
I can tell you first hand that the centers break out.  I was hit by one from another truck going the opposite direction once.  It was not pretty.  I also had one come off a trailer coming out of New Jersey and that one nearly hit a Buster Brown (UPS) truck.  Never did find that tire.  My boss was mad because he had to replace the tire.  He wanted me to pay for it.
Title: Re: Try to decide on new wheels Steel v Aluminum
Post by: luvrbus on July 10, 2014, 08:20:34 AM
Never said the centers didn't break on aluminum wheels,I have a friend in the heavy haul business I mean heavy 100 tons + he said the aluminum wheels work better for him not for weight but endurance so I don't know as I ran aluminum wheels all the way around on my haul truck (8 axles) not for the weight it wasn't important as we were all ways a permit load to begin with over weight and over width
Title: Re: Try to decide on new wheels Steel v Aluminum
Post by: TomC on July 10, 2014, 08:42:59 AM
The only real disadvantage to aluminum wheels is that if you kiss a curb, you can crack them (don't ask how I know). Steel wheels can bend. You can pound back a steel wheel if you bend it-been there done that with a big sledge. But-personally, all my trucks and bus have aluminum. Like the look and the vehicle does ride better without the additional unsprung weight of steel wheels. Good Luck, TomC
Title: Re: Try to decide on new wheels Steel v Aluminum
Post by: Van on July 10, 2014, 09:05:23 AM
To each his own, some prefer the look of the steely wheels and some the alum ones. Since installing our Alcoa's we have received many compliments on them. We waited to get them til it was time to get new rubber, haven't noticed any ride difference yet since our bus rides on a cloud as it is   ;D The shine of the alum is what really turns on the curb appeal and charm.  :)
Title: Re: Try to decide on new wheels Steel v Aluminum
Post by: luvrbus on July 10, 2014, 09:24:34 AM
I don't believe you can even order a Prevost bus with steel wheels I notice even the dogs have aluminum wheels, aluminum wheels are standard issue on the Prevost and have been for years 
Title: Re: Try to decide on new wheels Steel v Aluminum
Post by: CrabbyMilton on July 10, 2014, 10:50:12 AM
According to the spec sheets, the PREVOST H and PREVOST X list steel wheels as standard equipment for seated coaches but aluminum is standard on conversions shells.
Title: Re: Try to decide on new wheels Steel v Aluminum
Post by: luvrbus on July 10, 2014, 11:37:53 AM
That well could I never read the specs or pay much attention to seated coaches,I just walked by a Setra and Prevost one time in Needles and noticed the aluminum wheels on a dog never saw it before with that cheap outfit 
Title: Re: Try to decide on new wheels Steel v Aluminum
Post by: CrabbyMilton on July 10, 2014, 12:55:45 PM
It would be neat if those old DAYTON style wheels(spoke with demountable rim) were still offered. They never as far as I could tell were available on North American transit and over the road buses but were very popular on skookies until about the late 90's to early '00's and then steel disc and aluminum were and are the choices. With good reasons they stopped offering them but to imagine a MCI or PREVOST with those wheels would be interesting. Wheel covers could be used to cover up what many deemed ugly as far as wheels were concerned.
Title: Re: Try to decide on new wheels Steel v Aluminum
Post by: Connel on July 10, 2014, 06:57:44 PM
Am parting out my 05 Eagle. Replaced all the studs on my hubs but can not remember where they were purchased. Have the lug nuts you need and also have nine 24.5 alum wheels available.
papaseagle at g mail dot com
Title: Re: Try to decide on new wheels Steel v Aluminum
Post by: rusty on July 11, 2014, 05:48:59 AM
Connel, Does that 05 have a control valve and a slave cylinder on the clutch system. If so I am interested in those parts.

Wayne

303-591-0372
Title: Re: Try to decide on new wheels Steel v Aluminum
Post by: shelled on July 11, 2014, 11:41:25 AM
   I've wondered about chrome plated steel wheels. Anyone done that?

from Wikipedia :

"Hydrogen embrittlement can occur during various manufacturing operations or operational use - anywhere that the metal comes into contact with atomic or molecular hydrogen. Processes that can lead to this include cathodic protection, phosphating, pickling, and electroplating."

Chrome plating is done by electroplating.  If I remember correctly, unless special processing is done - as in OEM production - chrome plating structurally weakens wheels.

YMMV

edward